Gibbons Law Alert

Gibbons Law Alert

Tagged: Deleted Data Recovery

Court Sends a Strong “Signal”: Defendants Sanctioned Over Their Failure to Preserve Ephemeral Communications and Surreptitious Use of Encrypted Email

by

Posted in E-Discovery: Legal Decisions and Court Rules

On September 1, 2023

“The Individual Defendants’ systematic efforts to conceal and destroy evidence are deeply troubling and have cast a pall over this action.” These are some of the harsh words used by the Honorable Dominic W. Lanza, District Judge for the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, in Federal Trade Commission v. Noland, in lambasting the defendants for their deliberate deletion of cellphone messages sent via the Signal app and their suspension/clearing of email messages sent through ProtonMail (an encrypted email platform). One day after individual defendant James Noland became aware that the FTC was investigating him and his business Success by Health (SBH), he required the other individual defendants – who are all part of SBH’s leadership team – to start using a pair of encryption communications platforms: the Signal app for their cellphones and ProtonMail for email messaging relating to SBH’s business. After doing so, the individual defendants stopped using their previous messaging platforms for work-related communications and turned on Signal’s auto-delete function. After the FTC filed the action, it obtained a restraining order appointing a receiver to assume control over SBH and required the individual defendants to produce their electronic communications and turn over the mobile devices used to operate the business. In his deposition, Noland failed to disclose the Signal...

Non-Party E-Discovery Obligations in New York – A Question of Proportionality

by

Posted in E-Discovery: Legal Decisions and Court Rules

On January 17, 2012

In a rare New York State appellate decision concerning e-discovery, the First Department took the opportunity to address claims by a subpoenaed nonparty of inaccessibility of electronically stored information (ESI). The case, Tener v. Cremer, 2011 N.Y. Slip op. 6543 (1st Dep’t 2011), involved an alleged defamatory post originating from one of New York University’s computers. Plaintiff served NYU with a subpoena seeking identification of persons who accessed the Internet on a certain date via a certain IP address.

DuPont v. Kolon: A Lesson In How To Avoid Sanctions For Spoliation Of Evidence

by

Posted in E-Discovery: Legal Decisions and Court Rules

On September 6, 2011

Two recent decisions in the same case illustrate that, when it comes to imposing sanctions for spoliation of evidence, what matters is not simply whether you’ve intentionally deleted relevant evidence, but how you go about deleting it, and what the record reflects about your intentions. Although both the plaintiff and the defendant in E.I. du Pont De Nemours and Co. v. Kolon Industries, Inc., Civil Action No. 3:09cv58, demonstrated that the other intentionally destroyed relevant evidence, as is detailed below, the Court sanctioned only defendant Kolon Industries, Inc. (“Kolon”) based on its manifest bad faith (read the decision here). As is discussed in an earlier post on Gibbons’ E-Discovery Law Alert (which you can read here), plaintiff E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (“DuPont”) escaped a similar fate based on its demonstrable good faith. In short, this case teaches that the intentional deletion of relevant evidence does not per se lead to sanctions. Rather, the parties’ conduct — or misconduct, as the case may be — must be judged contextually.

How Useful is Facebook’s “Download Your Information” Feature in E-Discovery?

by

Posted in Litigation Preparedness and Strategies / Technology Developments and Issues

On May 11, 2011

In October 2010, Facebook announced a new Download Your Information (“DYI”) feature, billed as “an easy way to quickly download to your computer everything you’ve ever posted on Facebook and all your correspondences with friends: your messages, wall posts, photos, status updates and profile information.” The Facebook announcement included a short video detailing how to use the feature. Cnet TV has a more in-depth video. Craig Ball also wrote an article about this feature in the February 23, 2011 issue of Law Technology News.

Connect:

About Gibbons

With 200 attorneys, Gibbons is a leading law firm in New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Washington, DC, and Florida, ranked among the nation’s top 200 by The American Lawyer. More…

Subscribe

Archived Blog Posts

Categories